Human Rights: Senior State Department Reps in Vietnam
On May 29th, David Kramer, U.S. Assistant Secretary of State for Democracy, Human Rights and Labor, will lead a delegation to Hanoi to participate in a dialogue on U.S. - Vietnam Human Rights. In advance of those meeting, Dr. Ngai Nguyen, the Vice Secretary of the Democratic Party of Vietnam, just returned from three days of meetings in Washington, D.C. with key officials at the U.S. Department of State who will participate in the Hanoi meetings, and several Congressional leaders.
In meetings at the State Department with Dr. Michael Orona, Deputy Director of the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights & Labor, and Brett Blackshaw, Vietnam Desk Officer for the Office of Mainland Southeast Asia, Dr. Nguyen said that, “an ongoing U.S. - Vietnam dialogue can expand understanding between our two countries and peoples while consolidating human rights gains that have been won. However, actions speak louder than words.” Therefore, Dr. Nguyen asked that U.S. officials discuss the following issues with the Vietnam government at the meetings in Hanoi:
1. All political and religious prisoners who are still being jailed in Vietnam must be set free, unconditionally.
2. Unless major changes and improvements are made immediately, the U.S. State Department will recommend that Vietnam be redesignated a “country of particular concern” for its lack of democracy, human rights and religious freedom.
3. There must be substantial improvements in freedom of assembly, press, Internet and civil society.
Dr. Orona and Mr. Blackshaw, who will participate in the Hanoi meetings, assured Dr. Nguyen that these issues will be addressed, and that they expect some tangible results and actions from the Vietnamese government as a result of this dialogue on May 29th.
While in Washington, D.C., Dr. Nguyen also met with Congressman Dana Rohrabacher, who agreed to place an additional ten names in the U.S. Congressional Record of political and religious prisoners recently detained by the Vietnam government. Mr. Rohrabacher, at the request of Dr. Nguyen in 2007, placed the names of 85 prisoners in the Congressional Record.
Congresswoman Zoe Lofgren, following a meeting with Dr. Nguyen, agreed to send a letter signed by her Congressional colleagues to President Bush and Secretary Rice condemning the ongoing human rights abuses in Vietnam, and demanding that there be substantial progress in the Human Rights Dialogue in Hanoi May 29 towards the release of its political and religious prisoners or they would recommend Vietnam be returned to the CPC list.
Dr. Nguyen, on this trip to Washington, D.C., thanked the various U.S. officials for their continued efforts to bring about real change in Vietnam, but said, “talk is cheap, and it is time to see significant actions and results from the government of Vietnam.”
Contact:
Democratic Party of Vietnam, Overseas Office Dr. Ngai Nguyen, 1-408-603-5030 ngainguyen@aol.com Related: Vietnam expels American pro-democracy activist
June 6, 2008 at 9:16 am
Comments for the 13th round of dialogue on human rights in Hanoi on May 29 2008.
Dear Mr. David Kramer and others,
Please send some time to read our comments for the diologue on human rights in Hanoi on May 29, 2008:
Lieutenant General Nguyen Van Huong said in the dialogue with the Assistant Secretary (Mr. David Kramer) in Hanoi on 3/6/2008 in the annual:
“I suggest that the US side should not interfere too deeply into the internal affairs of Vietnam”.
Vietnam has signed a lot of commitments, agreements and treaties for human rights and anti-corruption… with international organizations. So fighting corruption or arrest any citizen without prove is the internal affairs of Vietnam?
The following are some examples of human rights are seriously violated as reported by Vietnamese press:
The wife cut to get blood to write complaints to claim justice for husband, sold blood to get money for transport fees, Mr. Son was imprisoned because of nothing:
http://vnexpress.net/GL/Phap-luat/2006/08/3B9ED527/
Or let’s search on a well-known Vietnamese newspaper - Tien phong, type: “Bồi thường oan sai” (Compensation for wrongful conviction/unjust cases) to see how many hits you have:
http://www.tienphong.vn/Tianyon/Index.aspx?SearchQuery=%22b%E1%BB%93i+th%C6%B0%E1%BB%9Dng+oan+sai%22&cboInputMethod=1
Or please search on Tuoi tre newspaper, type: “Bồi thường oan sai” (Compensation for wrongful conviction/unjust cases) to see how many hits you have:
http://www.tuoitre.com.vn/Tianyon/Index.aspx?SearchQuery=%22%E2%80%9CB%E1%BB%93i+th%C6%B0%E1%BB%9Dng+oan+sai%E2%80%9D%22&Select1=0
Please ask Lieutenant General Nguyen Van Huong why the National Assembly standing Committee promulgated the Resolution No. 388 regarding to the compensation for wrongful/injustice convictions/cases??? How many wrongful and unjust convictions, arrests in Vietnam, and how much (how many billion VND) was spent for these cases? You can see the statistics in the following article in Vietnamese:
According to report No. 1350/UBPL11 of National assembly standing committee session 11, to date (24/10/2005) there were 177 unjust cases (wrong convictions). More than 2.291 billion VND was compensated for the wrongful and injustice cases:
http://www.vnmedia.vn/print.asp?newsid=44426
Mr. Nguyen Dinh Chien was arrested and imprisoned wrongfully, please visit the page in English:
http://www.thanhniennews.com/society/?cati…mp;newsid=18594
http://english.vietnamnet.vn/social/2008/05/783314/
http://www.thanhniennews.com/society/?catid=3&newsid=38522
In particular, the case of Mr. Nguyen Lam Sau, who has been fighting against corruption, was imprisoned for combating corruption. He was arrested but not in the lawful manner: no approval of People’s Procurary, no criminal evidence ((only 0.65 Mly (what Mly is?, and if it is milliliter, 0.65 ml is as big as a water drop) of spoiled oranges oil essential, no hearing, no trial, he only received an Order of temporary release. He and his wife had no salary, no rice portion, nothing… Mr. Nguyen Lam Sau has been claiming justice for nearly 3 decades, but the case remains unsolved. Does Mr. Huong know this case? :
Articles in Vietnamese:
http://www.tienphong.vn/Tianyon/Index.aspx?SearchQuery=%22Nguy%E1%BB%85n+L%C3%A2m+S%C3%A1u%22&cboInputMethod=1
Articles in English, translated from 4 above articles and others:
http://blog.360.yahoo.com/blog-MRRjoJ03cqjTRAeReg6n42SYeLg-?cq=1&p=6
Please see all the articles:
http://blog.360.yahoo.com/blog-MRRjoJ03cqjTRAeReg6n42SYeLg-?cq=1
It is apparent that the police can arrest whoever they want without any criminal evidence, not like Mr. Huong said (“Both the Assistant Secretary and the Ambassador should understand that Vietnam is a country that has sovereignty and laws. It is not that if we want to arrest [someone] we arrest [them]”).
Please bring these cases to Lieutenant General Nguyen Van Huong and ask who provide wrong information, and why people who provide wrong information or the information is fabricated are not arrested and imprisoned?
Did the case of Mr. Nguyen Lam Sau and others such as reporters (fighting against corruption and report corruption cases in lawful manner) “respect the interests of the nation” and damage to the interests of organizations and individuals”?
Please also raise your voice to claim justice for those who suffer from unjust imprisonment by Vietnamese police.
Thanks you and all the best.